Commentary: How to see the common ground
while bombs are landing around you Juliette Schmidt
July
25, 2006
BEIRUT -- As a Canadian,
I have so far been spared the stress, anxiety, and heartbreak of
living through a violent conflict that is the center of the world's
attention. Yet here I find myself, just north of Beirut, sitting in
a glassed-in balcony overlooking the American embassy and the
Mediterranean - nine of us plus a dog in a three-bedroom apartment.
For the last seven days we have been listening with
heavy hearts to explosions throughout a country that is as beautiful
as it is resilient, full of friends and stories.
Clearly,
Hizbullah crossed a not-so-imaginary line when they kidnapped two
Israeli soldiers from the wrong side of Lebanon's southern border
and, as Israel retaliated, followed with rocket attacks on
increasingly-civilian targets in northern Israel.
Israel has
been raining bombs on strategic targets in Lebanon causing great
damage to infrastructure throughout the country at the cost of many
civilian lives. The political commentators calmly discuss events day
and night and consider greater implications and root causes.
Watching these discussions, it is hard to see any room for a
resolution that will be satisfactory to both parties. In fact, it is
hard to see any opportunity for a resolution at all.
Sitting
here in the heat and humidity of a Lebanese summer with the sporadic
relief of air conditioning when the electricity comes on, I imagine
that those in the bomb shelters in northern Israel must not feel
very different.
Empathizing with our neighbors to the south
is not so popular up here, but it seems that we have a few things in
common at the moment. Not only are there mounting civilian deaths in
each country, but individuals are tense and hot, waiting and
watching, on both sides of the border.
In addition, my
limited experience living in a country being bombarded by another is
that having bombs dropped on you doesn't quite generate goodwill for
the perpetrator.
As a result, military bombardment is only a
short-term distraction from a more complicated problem. It has
disastrous side effects not only for those involved, but for anyone
with an interest in the Middle East.
These days, this
"anyone" is generally a good proportion of the world population - it
is East and West alike. This is obvious from the amount of press
coverage and international attention that has been given to this
situation.
The international community, or more accurately
American and European governments and the UN Security Council, are
going to play a significant role in the outcome of this conflict.
And here we come to the most pressing question: what is the
most effective role for this larger Western contingent?
First of all, the international community needs to call for
a ceasefire immediately and empower the Lebanese government to
deploy the Lebanese army in the south to deal with the situation
internally as they have indicated they are prepared to do.
By refusing to pressure both sides of the conflict to stop,
they are indirectly sanctioning the continuing volley of missiles
from both parties and perpetuating anger and hatred that will linger
long after the explosions stop.
Second, longer term
solutions need to be considered. This most recent flare-up is not an
isolated problem. In the aftermath of the Israeli incursion, the
Lebanese will not only have to rebuild, they will have to continue
their national dialogue around this event and all its implications
sitting squarely on the table.
Meanwhile, Israelis will
still find themselves living between two angry populations. The
international community needs to publicly support opportunities for
dialogue and facilitate it when necessary.
Third, the human
element must be addressed. There are people on each side of the
conflict, people who can influence the actions of their governments
and local leaders. At the moment there is very limited interaction
between Lebanese and Israelis.
It is unreasonable to believe
that this will change instantly with the cessation of violence,
however, human stories need to get out and in forums where Lebanese
and Israelis are able to come together - in online chat rooms, in
comment sections of regional newspapers, and in the Diaspora -
interaction must be encouraged and enabled.
International
media and high-level spokespeople can be powerful vehicles to get
diverse stories and opinions on both sides into the spotlight in a
non-inflammatory way, beginning a process that can lead to greater
communication between groups.
As I sit here in front of a
stunning sunset signalling the end of yet another day and the
beginning of another night, I listen in the dark for the sound of
explosions. We hope this will be the last such night. These
neighbors will still have to live beside each other tomorrow.
Juliette Schmidt is a Canadian citizen working in Beirut
for Search for Common Ground. She is Assistant Director of the
Partners in Humanity program. Acknowledgement to the Common Ground
News Service